One possible thing that we could learn from other countries
is to understand disability as a human right rather than a civil right. Initially, one would think that disability
rights are human rights endowed to every person simply by his or her existence
as a human being; however, the more that I think about it, the more that I
think framing disability in terms of civil rights might be more helpful in our
society than framing disability in terms of human rights. In coming to this conclusion, I understand
that other countries do not have the history of fighting for civil rights that
the United States has. After recognizing
a fight for civil rights by other marginalized groups of people in the past,
our country has moved in a positive direction to acknowledge those rights,
enforce those rights, and change societal attitudes about those rights. We cannot say if those rights would have
gained support had they been framed as human rights. Although fighting for civil rights in every
sphere is a continuing job, the fight for civil rights for other groups has
proven successful, and therefore, may be the best approach to disability
rights. I recognize that in many ways,
disability rights are different from other types of rights; however, I also
acknowledge that the fight for disability rights is similar to the rights that
many other minority groups have fought for throughout the history of the United
States. The interaction between
disability rights and other things that we consider civil rights is
important. I believe it is vital to
understand that the struggles many individuals with disabilities have gone
through mimic the struggles of other minority groups throughout our history. In recognizing that other groups have been
successful in taking a civil rights approach, I think that those fighting for
disability rights might also be successful in taking a civil rights
approach. Therefore, a human rights
approach might not be the most appropriate approach to disability in the United
States.
Another thing that we can arguably learn from other
countries is to broaden the definition of disability and not speak in terms of
a reasonable accommodation. It would be
ideal to have the rights of any person who identifies as a person with a
disability protected and to have any accommodations necessary to make access
equal. However, the more I think about
this in terms of the United States, the more I recognize that this might be too
idealistic and not very realistic. While
I do think that we should attempt to broaden the definition of disability and
not speak in terms of a reasonable accommodation, I recognize that it is very
unlikely that would be possible considering our current political system. In order to have a bill passed, a majority of
the Senate and House of Representative must agree. To assuage concerns of representatives and their
constituents, certain concessions needed to be made. These concessions included limiting the
definition of disability and limiting the required actions to only those that
would be “reasonable accommodations.” While
it might be ideal to change our approach to disability in the law, I do not
think it is possible at this point, considering our political system. Prior to changing the law, I believe we must
change attitudes about disability.
I think we could learn from other countries in some ways and
other countries can learn from us in some ways how to change attitudes around
disability. In my opinion, education around
disability is the most important part about recognizing disability in the law
and in society generally. We should
recognize that people with disabilities are people who deserve equal treatment. We should work towards inclusion in the same
way that we would for people of different races, of different ethnicities, and
with different socio-economic statuses.
We should recognize that ideas around disability will forever be
changing as our understanding of medicine and social dynamics change. We should ultimately work to enlighten
ourselves. We can acknowledge where
other countries have succeeded and where they have failed in their approach to
disability. This is how we will change
attitudes, and ultimately change the law to reflect an equal and inclusive
society.